New Batch is Starting Soon - Enroll in the Course Now New Batch is Starting Soon - Enroll in the Course Now
Vibrant Indian street food stall showcasing steaming dishes and colourful ingredients at a busy Ahmedabad market.

Vegetarian Stock at Home: What Five Published Recipes Use, and How to Test a Version for Your Household

Updated 3 November 2026 · 10 min read

Vegetarian stock at home is one of the quietest upgrades a cook in Ahmedabad can make. It turns vegetable trimmings and a few herbs into a base for soup, curry and rice, and you control the salt. There is a catch for Jain and other root-free households in Gujarat. All five published recipes we read use onion or garlic, and every one also uses carrot, potato or radish.

This guide compares those recipes, outlines a test batch using ratios borrowed from them, and sets out how to cool and store stock safely. Every quantity comes from named publishers, not from our own test batches. Jain practice varies by household, so we make no Jain claim about any recipe or ingredient. For general substitutes, see our guide to Jain root-vegetable substitutes.

Key Takeaways
– The five published stock recipes we read simmer for 15 to 60 minutes, and all five contain onion or garlic.
– Pew found that 67% of Jains in India abstain from root vegetables such as garlic and onion, so household practice differs.
– Cool stock quickly. NHS Forth Valley says ideally into the fridge or freezer within an hour, and to use it within 2 days. Nebraska Extension allows 3 to 4 days.
– The glutamate table we cite covers raw foods and does not test stock. Treat any root-free build as your own test, not a sourced recipe.

Want to learn this hands-on?

Florence Academy's courses are 100% vegetarian, with Jain-adapted recipes available. Join 2,000+ students who have trained with expert chefs at Florence Academy, Ahmedabad.

Chat with us on WhatsAppCulinary Foundation Program →

What Is Vegetarian Stock at Home, and How Is It Different From Broth?

In this guide, stock means a strained, lightly seasoned liquid you use as a base for cooking, and broth means one seasoned enough to sip. That is our usage. The sources we read use “stocks or broths” together without a firm line, so treat the difference as a convention.

What Do Five Published Vegetable Stock Recipes Use?

They agree on a gentle simmer and a strained result, and differ on amounts. The table below uses quantities as the publishers print them, and the ratio column uses only printed figures.

Recipe Main vegetables Water Vegetables to water Simmer Sauté first
Pick Up Limes 2 onions, 4 garlic cloves, 2 carrots, 2 celery ribs, 4 cups scraps 6 cups Not stated About 1 hour Not mentioned
Archana’s Kitchen 3 carrots, onion, spring onion, mushrooms, celery, garlic 10 cups Not stated About 30 minutes Yes, about 10 minutes
LoveFood (Jo Pratt) 2 onions, 2 carrots, 2 leeks, fennel, celery, 4 garlic cloves 4 litres Not stated 45 minutes Yes, about 5 minutes
Harvard Nutrition Source Leeks, onion, garlic, potatoes, mushrooms, carrot, celery To cover Not stated 1 hour Not mentioned
Hebbar’s Kitchen (scrap broth) 3 cups scraps, including onion, carrot, potato, cabbage, radish, ginger, garlic 5 cups 3 cups to 5 cups 15 minutes Not mentioned

Sources: Pick Up Limes, Archana’s Kitchen (2018), LoveFood, Harvard T.H. Chan School and Hebbar’s Kitchen (2021). Hebbar’s is a scrap broth, which is a different product from a full stock.

Three differences matter in practice. First, simmer time runs from 15 to 60 minutes. Pick Up Limes warns against a very long or rapid simmer, which it says may make the broth bitter. Second, two recipes sauté the vegetables first, and the other three do not mention it. Third, Pick Up Limes tells you to avoid cruciferous vegetables such as broccoli, cauliflower, kale and cabbage, and onion skins, because they can turn the broth bitter, while Hebbar’s scrap broth includes cabbage and cauliflower.

Salt differs too: Pick Up Limes uses 1 teaspoon, LoveFood 2 teaspoons and Hebbar’s half a teaspoon, and Archana’s and Harvard list none. We found no source that says vegetable stock needs less time than meat stock. Hebbar’s suggests using its broth in soup, curry or flavoured rice.

Dried bay leaves in a carved wooden bowl beside a metal spoonful of dried rosemary on a dark wooden table

What Should Jain and Root-Free Households Know?

Practice differs, and no recipe we read is root-free. The Government of Gujarat’s Kachchh district site says Jains refrain from kandmool, foods grown below the ground such as potatoes, garlic, onion and yam (District Kachchh, Government of Gujarat, 2018).

Pew Research reported in 2021 that two-thirds of Jains in India (67%) go beyond vegetarianism by abstaining from root vegetables such as garlic and onion, and that eating root vegetables is seen as a form of violence in Jain teachings (Pew Research Center, 6 facts about Jains in India, 2021). So household practice differs, and you should ask each household what it follows.

Every recipe in the table includes at least one of onion, garlic, carrot, potato or radish. We make no claim about which other vegetables a household accepts, and we also do not cover asafoetida, where practice differs, as our Kathiyawadi guide explains. For how we teach this, see our Jain cooking classes in Ahmedabad.

What Does a Flavour Table Say, and What Does It Not?

The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics publishes a white paper on umami. It explains that free glutamic acid triggers the umami response, and that glutamate bound to protein is tasteless (Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, Umami in Foods white paper, 2013). Its table gives free glutamic acid in a long list of foods. A selection:

Food Free glutamic acid (mg per 100 g)
Tomato 140 to 246
Broccoli 176
Green peas 106
Corn 106
Onion 51
Cabbage 50
Carrot 33

This table is context and not evidence about stock. It does not test stock, and it does not say whether the values are for raw or cooked foods. It does not explain why a vegetable stock might taste flat, so we claim no cause. The white paper also says that moist-heat cooking with stocks or broths as a base releases free glutamic acid, but the study behind that line used chicken stock, so applying it to vegetable stock is our inference.

We do not say which of these foods your household accepts. If your household avoids onion, garlic and roots, the idea we would test is this: build a small batch from ingredients your household already accepts, use the table as one reference, and taste and take notes as you go. That is our own suggestion to test, and it is not a sourced recipe or a Jain ruling.

How Do You Run a Test Batch?

Borrow a ratio, keep the simmer gentle, and season at the end. This outline uses figures from the recipes above, so you can compare your result with a published one.

  1. Choose your ratio. Hebbar’s uses 3 cups of scraps to 5 cups of water, and Pick Up Limes uses about 4 cups of scraps plus vegetables to 6 cups of water.
  2. Wash everything, then chop it into similar sizes.
  3. Simmer gently. The recipes range from 15 to 60 minutes, so taste at intervals. Four of the five recipes use bay leaf.
  4. Strain through a fine sieve, pressing lightly, and discard the solids.
  5. Season at the end, since recipes range from no salt to 2 teaspoons. Pick Up Limes uses 1 teaspoon for 6 cups.
  6. Keep notes on the ratio, the simmer time and what you would change.

How Do You Cool and Store Vegetarian Stock at Home Safely?

Cool it fast and keep it cold, and use the shorter of the two sources’ times. Our table of steps combines the University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension (Serving Soup Safely) and an NHS Forth Valley leaflet (Safe Storage of Leftover Food, 2023):

  1. Do not put a large hot pot straight into the fridge. Nebraska Extension says so directly.
  2. Move stock to shallow containers. Nebraska says no deeper than two inches (about 5 cm), and NHS Forth Valley suggests a shallow bowl of cold water to speed cooling.
  3. Get it cold quickly. NHS Forth Valley says into the fridge or freezer ideally within an hour, and Nebraska says no more than two hours at room temperature.
  4. Use it within 2 days, or freeze. NHS Forth Valley says 2 days in the fridge and no more than 2 months frozen. Nebraska says 3 to 4 days, or freeze.
  5. Reheat until steaming hot. Nebraska says at least 165°F (about 74°C), and NHS Forth Valley says not to reheat food more than once.

Freeze in small portions, so you reheat only what you need. For storage in warm weather, our guide to meal prep in India’s heat covers a related problem.

Ready to learn from expert chefs? Explore Courses at Florence Academy →

Fresh green peas in a fine mesh strainer with water splashing around it against a black background

What This Guide Does Not Verify

We want to be plain about the limits. We did not find a tested root-free stock recipe, a standard definition of stock versus broth, or FSSAI, USDA or FDA guidance on cooling stock, so the safety steps rest on the two sources above. We make no claim about asafoetida, mushrooms, seaweed or any vegetable’s status in a Jain kitchen. Ask the household, and read every label.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should I simmer vegetable stock?

The five recipes we read give 15 to 60 minutes: Hebbar’s 15, Archana’s about 30, LoveFood 45, and Pick Up Limes and Harvard about an hour. Only Pick Up Limes warns that a very long or rapid simmer may make the broth bitter. Keep the simmer gentle, and taste at intervals.

Can I make vegetable stock without onion or garlic?

We found no tested recipe, so we cannot give a verified method. Every recipe we read uses onion or garlic. If your household avoids them, test a small batch with ingredients it accepts, and keep notes. That is our own suggestion, not a sourced recipe or a Jain ruling.

How long does homemade stock keep?

Use it within 2 days or freeze it, following the shorter source. NHS Forth Valley says 2 days in the fridge and no more than 2 months frozen, while Nebraska Extension says 3 to 4 days or freeze. Cool it in shallow containers first, and reheat it only once.

Do Jains avoid vegetables used in stock?

Practice differs. The Kachchh district site says Jains refrain from foods grown below the ground such as potatoes, garlic and onion, and Pew found that 67% of Jains in India abstain from root vegetables such as garlic and onion. Ask each household what it follows, and list every ingredient you use.

Can I freeze vegetable stock?

Yes, according to both sources we cite. Nebraska Extension says to eat refrigerated soup within 3 to 4 days or freeze it, and NHS Forth Valley says to freeze for no more than 2 months. Cool it first, freeze it in small portions, and write the date on each container.

Conclusion

Vegetarian stock at home is forgiving, but the published recipes assume onion, garlic and root vegetables. If your household avoids them, treat any root-free version as a test, keep notes, and cool and store every batch carefully.

  • Expect differences: simmer times run from 15 to 60 minutes, and sautéing is optional.
  • Know your household’s rules: no recipe we read is root-free, and Jain practice varies.
  • Treat the flavour table as context: it does not test stock.
  • Cool it fast: ideally within an hour, in shallow containers.
  • Use the shorter storage time: 2 days in the fridge, or freeze.

About the author: Chef Monila Surana is Managing Partner and lead culinary educator at Florence Academy of World Cuisines, Ahmedabad, with 18 years of experience in culinary education and curriculum design.

Want to learn kitchen fundamentals from expert chefs? See our Culinary Foundation Program, or start with our guide to essential knife skills. Join 2,000+ students who’ve trained with expert chefs at Florence Academy, Ahmedabad.

Ready to learn from expert chefs? Explore Courses at Florence Academy →

Call us at +91 6351665305 | +91 8320715588

Have questions? Chat with us on WhatsApp — we respond fast.

Get Started

Start Your Course Today!

Illustration for the “which cooking course is right for you” quiz section on the Florence Academy homepage
Florence Academy of World Cuisines student practicing in the kitchen
Florence Academy of World Cuisines student practicing in the kitchen
Florence Academy of World Cuisines student practicing in the kitchen

Trusted by over 2K+ students

Inquire Now