An eggless fruit cake is one of the few bakes that suits both Diwali boxes and Christmas tables, and a home baker in Ahmedabad can make it without eggs or alcohol. The catch is that published recipes disagree on almost everything: the binder, the sweetener, how long to soak the fruit and how long to bake.
This guide puts five published recipes side by side, using the quantities each page prints. We have not baked these recipes ourselves, so we report what the pages say and mark our own suggestions as suggestions. If you are new to eggless baking, start with our eggless baking substitute guide.
Key Takeaways
– The five recipes we read bake at about 160 to 180 degrees for 35 minutes to 1.5 hours, depending on the recipe. One page prints no temperature unit.
– Two use curd or yogurt as the binder, and the rest rely on baking soda and baking powder, with vinegar, lemon juice or milk.
– Sources give different advice on coating fruit in flour, so treat it as a habit, not a guarantee.
– Quality can drop before safety does. One recipe author says use within about a week, and another says refrigerate after a day or two in humid weather.
Want to learn this hands-on?
Florence Academy's courses are 100% vegetarian, with Jain-adapted recipes available. Join 2,000+ students who have trained with expert chefs at Florence Academy, Ahmedabad.
What Do Five Published Eggless Fruit Cake Recipes Have in Common?
All five are plain batters with dried fruit folded in, baked at 160 to 180 degrees. They differ in binder, sweetener and soak. The table shows each page’s printed figures.
| Recipe | Binder or lift | Fat | Sweetener | Fruit treatment | Bake |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hebbar’s Kitchen (Kerala plum cake, 2020) | 130 g curd, plus baking powder and soda | 250 g butter and 50 g oil | 300 g brown sugar | About 850 g fruit, soaked 200 ml grape juice for 8 hours or more | 160 degrees (no unit printed), 1.5 hours, 7-inch tin |
| Swasthi’s Recipes | Baking soda reacting with 1 tbsp vinegar or lemon juice | 80 ml oil or melted butter | 170 to 200 g brown sugar | About 150 g fruit, hot water poured over, plus 120 ml juice in the batter | 170 degrees, about 40 minutes, 8-inch pan |
| Yummy Tummy Aarthi | 120 ml yogurt and 120 ml milk, plus baking powder and soda | 120 ml oil | 150 g sugar plus a caramel from 65 g sugar | Fruit boiled 5 minutes in orange juice for the no-rum route | 180 degrees, 1 hour 20 minutes, 9-inch pan |
| I Camp in My Kitchen (boiled fruit cake) | Baking powder and soda | Half a cup of melted butter | Caramel from 1 cup jaggery or sugar | Fruit boiled in 1 cup apple juice, then cooled | 170 degrees, 35 to 40 minutes, small pans |
| I Camp in My Kitchen (apricot raisin) | Baking powder and soda | 100 g melted butter | 210 g jaggery dissolved in 250 ml milk | 125 g fruit tossed in dry mix, no soak | 160 degrees, about 40 minutes, 8-inch pan |
Sources: Hebbar’s Kitchen (December 2020), Swasthi’s Recipes, Yummy Tummy Aarthi, I Camp in My Kitchen, boiled fruit cake and I Camp in My Kitchen, apricot raisin cake. Only the Hebbar’s page shows a date, and its bake temperature has no unit printed (we assume Celsius). These are food blogs, not tested standards, and fruit weights differ a lot between them.
Some of these pages also list rum or brandy as an option for soaking. We cover only the juice and boiling routes. Hebbar’s says the curd is a good replacement for eggs, and the page offers grape, orange or apple juice for the soak.

How Do the Binder, Fat and Sweetener Change the Cake?
We found no source that compares these choices in a lab test, so what follows is a description of the recipes, not a verdict. Pick one recipe and keep its ratios, because the five are balanced differently.
Binder. Two recipes use curd or yogurt (Hebbar’s curd, and Yummy Tummy Aarthi’s yogurt plus milk). The apricot raisin cake dissolves its jaggery in milk, and the other two have no dairy binder, so the rise comes from baking powder and soda, plus vinegar or lemon juice in the Swasthi’s version. We read no recipe that uses flax, applesauce or condensed milk.
Fat. The choices are butter only (the two I Camp recipes), oil only (Swasthi’s can use either, and Yummy Tummy Aarthi uses oil), or butter with a little oil (Hebbar’s). Hebbar’s uses 300 g of butter and oil with 300 g of maida.
Sweetener. Brown sugar, plain sugar, a sugar caramel, a jaggery caramel, or jaggery melted in milk. The I Camp boiled fruit cake and the Yummy Tummy Aarthi cake both build a caramel first. The apricot raisin cake skips it and uses whole wheat flour.
How Should You Soak or Boil the Fruit Without Alcohol?
The published routes run from nothing to eight hours. Hebbar’s soaks the fruit in grape, orange or apple juice for at least 8 hours, or until the fruit absorbs the juice. Yummy Tummy Aarthi boils the fruit in orange juice for 5 minutes and cools it, and I Camp boils it in apple juice and cools it. Swasthi’s pours hot water over the fruit, and the apricot raisin cake does not soak at all.
King Arthur’s classic fruitcake page, which uses eggs and so is not a recipe for you, offers apple or cranberry juice as an alternative to liquor and suggests either an overnight soak or a one-minute microwave plus one hour (King Arthur Baking, 2015). That is a different quick route from the 5-minute boil, so it is not a direct match.
Drain well before folding the fruit in, or the extra liquid may thin the batter. That is our suggestion, not a sourced step.
Why Does Fruit Sink, and Does Flour Coating Help?
Sources give different advice, and they cover different foods. Silver Spoon, a British sugar brand, says a light dusting of flour helps dried fruit cling to the batter and that large pieces such as glace cherries should be halved or quartered first (Silver Spoon). 177 Milk Street says add-ins are denser than batter, and that coating does not prevent sinking and can leave dry pockets (177 Milk Street). Its article is about berries and muffins, not rich fruit cakes.
So treat the flour dusting as a common habit and not a guarantee. 177 Milk Street’s view is that a batter with enough structure holds add-ins better. Our own suggestion is to keep the batter thick, not runny, and to drain soaked fruit well. For related causes of a collapsed centre, see our guide to why cakes sink in the middle.
Ready to learn from expert chefs? Explore Courses at Florence Academy →

How Do You Bake It So the Outside Does Not Burn?
Hebbar’s says to bake at a low temperature so the outside does not burn while the inside stays raw, and it uses a 7-inch tin, 4 inches high, lined with butter paper. The other four recipes bake at 160 to 180 degrees, and times run from 35 minutes to 1 hour 20 minutes. Yummy Tummy Aarthi says to tent the top with foil if it darkens, and not to overbake or the cake turns hard.
King Arthur fills its pans about three-quarters full and bakes at about 150 degrees, with 75 minutes for small loaves and about 2 hours 10 minutes for larger ones. Those times are for its own egg batter, so do not copy them. Use the toothpick test the Hebbar’s page describes, and start checking early in a smaller pan.
Hebbar’s also pours a cherry syrup over the poked cake (2 tablespoons of cherries, a quarter cup of sugar and a cup of water, boiled for about 5 minutes) and rests it for at least an hour. The page says the syrup is optional.
How Do You Store Eggless Fruit Cake in Warm Weather?
Our suggestion is to refrigerate it after a day and eat it sooner than you would a liquor-soaked cake, because these juice, curd or milk recipes are moister than a classic dry fruitcake. NC State News reports that dried and candied fruit and nuts have low water activity, so most fruitcakes are very shelf stable, and that fruitcakes made with fresh fruit or a lot of moisture should be refrigerated and eaten soon (NC State News, updated November 2025). It also says quality can fall before safety does, through surface mould, fermenting sugars, and rancid fats and nuts.
The recipe authors are more cautious. Hebbar’s says to use the cake within about a week. I Camp in My Kitchen says room temperature for a day or two, then the fridge, because of hot and humid weather.
We found no reputable source giving a safe room-temperature shelf life for a juice-soaked, alcohol-free cake. NC State says nothing on alcohol-free cakes either. So our own suggestion for Gujarat is to wrap it well and refrigerate it after a day, and freeze what you will not eat soon. NC State reports quality for up to about a year frozen, citing the USDA, but we could not confirm that on the USDA’s own page, so for gifts, freeze only what you must (our suggestion, not a sourced limit).
For a Diwali box, name the nuts on the label, and say whether your kitchen also handles peanuts or other nuts. The US FDA says tree nuts and peanuts are among the major allergens and that “may contain” statements are voluntary (US FDA, 2023). That is a US rule, so the label advice here is ours, not an Indian requirement.
Can You Sell Eggless Fruit Cake for Diwali Boxes?
Whether you can sell it depends on your food licence status; our home bakery guide covers the setup. We found no data on how well dry fruit cakes sell. One Deccan Chronicle report from Hyderabad in October 2024 says many people gave dry fruit instead of traditional sweets, and that sweet makers were adding dry fruit to their range (Deccan Chronicle, 2024). That is one city’s local trade report, and it says nothing about cakes.
If you plan to sell, price it from your costs. Our baked goods pricing guide shows the method, and our corporate Diwali gifting guide covers bulk orders. For a drier gift item, see our eggless nankhatai.
Which Recipe Should You Try First?
Our suggestion, based only on the printed figures: if you want a no-soak cake, start with the apricot raisin recipe, which skips the soak and the caramel. If you want a rich, curd-based cake and have time to soak the fruit, start with Hebbar’s. For a no-alcohol boil in a jaggery caramel, try I Camp in My Kitchen’s boiled fruit cake. None of this comes from our own testing.
What This Guide Does Not Verify
We did not bake these recipes, and we did not verify other recipe sites. We found no tested guide on fruit sinking for rich fruit cakes, no sourced advice on ageing an alcohol-free cake, and no FSSAI or primary USDA page on shelf life. Check each recipe on its own page before you bake.
Frequently Asked Questions
What replaces eggs in a fruit cake?
In the five recipes we read, two use curd or yogurt: Hebbar’s adds 130 g of curd, which it calls a good egg replacement, and Yummy Tummy Aarthi uses yogurt and milk. The others rely on baking soda and powder, with vinegar, lemon juice or milk. We read no flax or applesauce version.
Can I make eggless fruit cake without alcohol?
Yes. The recipes we read use grape, orange or apple juice, a five-minute boil in juice, hot water, or no soak at all. Hebbar’s soaks fruit for at least 8 hours, while Yummy Tummy Aarthi boils it for 5 minutes in orange juice. Drain the fruit well before mixing it in.
Why does my fruit cake sink or turn dry?
Sources give different advice on sinking. Silver Spoon suggests a light flour dusting, while 177 Milk Street says coating does not prevent it and a batter with enough structure matters. For dryness, Yummy Tummy Aarthi warns that overbaking makes the cake hard, and Hebbar’s says skipping the syrup gives a drier cake.
How long does eggless fruit cake last?
We found no reputable source for juice-soaked, alcohol-free cakes. Hebbar’s suggests using its cake within about a week, and I Camp in My Kitchen says to refrigerate after a day or two in humid weather. NC State says quality can fall before safety does, so refrigerate and eat promptly.
Can I use whole wheat flour for fruit cake?
Two of the five recipes we read do. I Camp in My Kitchen’s boiled fruit cake uses 2 cups of whole wheat, and its apricot raisin cake uses 350 g. A third, Swasthi’s, allows atta or maida. We found no source comparing the textures, so keep the recipe’s own ratios.
Conclusion
An eggless fruit cake is forgiving, but the published recipes are not interchangeable. Pick one, keep its ratios, and bake low and slow.
- Choose your binder: curd in two recipes, leavening and acid in the rest.
- Skip the alcohol: juice soaks and short boils both appear in the recipes.
- Treat flour coating as a habit: sources disagree on whether it works.
- Refrigerate in warm weather: one author says use within about a week and another says refrigerate after a day or two, so freeze gifts you will not hand over soon.
- Label the nuts: name them for anyone you gift to.
About the author: Chef Monila Surana is Managing Partner and lead culinary educator at Florence Academy of World Cuisines, Ahmedabad, with 18 years of experience in culinary education and curriculum design.
Want to bake with expert chefs? See our Cake Engineering course or the Bakery Foundation Program. Join 2,000+ students who’ve trained with expert chefs at Florence Academy, Ahmedabad.
Ready to learn from expert chefs? Explore Courses at Florence Academy →
Call us at +91 6351665305 | +91 8320715588
Have questions? Chat with us on WhatsApp — we respond fast.