New Batch is Starting Soon - Enroll in the Course Now New Batch is Starting Soon - Enroll in the Course Now
Crispy cone dosa served with authentic Indian chutneys and sambar on a dark backdrop

Winter Vegetable Soups at Home: Six Recipes Checked for Onion, Garlic and Roots

Updated 11 November 2026 · 9 min read

As Ahmedabad evenings cool in November, a bowl of soup becomes an easy dinner. For many Gujarati households the first question is not which soup, but whether it uses onion, garlic or a root vegetable. All six published recipes we read do. For more winter cooking, see our Gujarati winter food guide.

We read six published recipes from three Indian recipe sites and marked every onion, garlic, ginger and carrot. We also read one soup listed in a Jain recipe collection to see what it does differently. Our own suggestions are labelled as ours, and we did not cook these recipes for this guide. For the stock itself, read our vegetarian stock guide; this post does not repeat it.

Key Takeaways
– All six published recipes we read use garlic. Four use onion and one uses spring onion. Four use ginger, carrot or both.
– The Jain-listed tomato soup we read simply leaves those out. It adds no substitute and thickens with cornflour dissolved in milk.
– The six recipes get their body in four ways: blending, cream, a butter-and-flour roux, or a cornflour slurry.
– The only verified Jain soup we found adds no substitute for onion or garlic.
– A blender manufacturer warns that hot liquids can spray or release steam and cause burns, so start on the lowest speed.

Want to learn this hands-on?

Florence Academy's courses are 100% vegetarian, with Jain-adapted recipes available. Join 2,000+ students who have trained with expert chefs at Florence Academy, Ahmedabad.

Chat with us on WhatsAppCulinary Foundation Program →

What Do Six Published Winter Vegetable Soups Use?

Garlic in every one, and onion or spring onion in five. This is what each recipe lists.

Soup and source Onion Garlic Ginger Carrot Body comes from Liquid
Cream of tomato, Hebbar’s Kitchen Yes Yes No Yes Blending, then cream Water
Palak, Hebbar’s Kitchen Yes Yes Yes No Butter and maida roux, milk, cream Milk (puree ground with water)
Pumpkin, Hebbar’s Kitchen Yes Yes No No Blending the pumpkin Water
Sweet corn, Swasthi’s Recipes Spring onion Yes Optional Yes Cornflour slurry, corn puree Water or stock
Dal (masoor, moong, toor), Hebbar’s Kitchen No Yes Yes Yes Blending the cooked dal Water
Lauki, Cooking and Me Yes Yes No No Moong dal and lauki, blended Water

Hebbar’s tomato soup uses three tomatoes, half an onion, two garlic cloves and half a carrot, blended and finished off the heat: “Turn off the flame and add 2 tbsp cream, mix well” (Hebbar’s Kitchen). Its palak soup builds a base of butter, maida and four cups of milk, and warns: “Do not brown the onions as the flavour will change” (Hebbar’s Kitchen).

The pumpkin soup uses 400 g of pumpkin with one onion and two garlic cloves, and its notes say it “can be extended by adding potato and carrot while boiling” (Hebbar’s Kitchen). The dal soup is the only one without onion, but it still lists garlic, ginger and a carrot (Hebbar’s Kitchen).

A close-up of smooth orange pumpkin soup in a speckled ceramic bowl, topped with pumpkin seeds, with a spoon dipped into it

A bright green spinach soup in a wide black bowl, topped with pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, black sesame, a dark sauce drizzle and a sprig of fresh herbs

Swasthi’s sweet corn soup uses spring onion, garlic, carrot and beans, with ginger marked optional (Swasthi’s Recipes, updated 2023). The lauki soup from Cooking and Me, a personal food blog, cooks four cups of lauki with three-quarters of a cup of moong dal, half a cup of onion, and garlic (Cooking and Me, 2015).

What Does a Jain-Listed Soup Do Differently?

It leaves the onion and garlic out and adds nothing in their place. The tomato soup in Jainworld’s Jain recipe collection lists tomatoes, seven cups of water, one and a half cups of milk, a teaspoon of corn flour, butter, optional cream, pepper, salt and fried bread (Jainworld). The tomatoes are pressure cooked and sieved, and the corn flour is dissolved in milk and boiled.

We found no other verified Jain soup recipe. Several Jain-labelled soups on Tarla Dalal could not be opened, so we do not describe them.

Which Soup Ingredients Do Jain Households Avoid?

Root vegetables, and sometimes more. Pew Research Center reports that “a majority of Indian Jains (67%) say they abstain from eating root vegetables” (Pew Research Center, 2021). Pew asked this of vegetarians, and its question gave garlic and onion as examples of root vegetables.

Jainworld explains that root vegetables are avoided because “vegetables grown underground are the depository of countless of small creatures.” It adds that “carrots, radishes etc. tuber-root, brinjal, cabbages and all root-vegetables are non-edibles for Jains” (Jainworld). So cabbage may not suit every Jain household either.

We found no reliable source on whether pumpkin, lauki, ginger or asafoetida (hing) is accepted in Jain cooking. Practice differs between families, so ask the household before you cook for it.

Ready to learn from expert chefs? Explore Courses at Florence Academy →

How Do These Soups Thicken Without Potato?

Four ways, and none of the six uses potato in its base. Blending gives body to the tomato, pumpkin, dal and lauki soups. Cream finishes the tomato and palak soups. Hebbar’s palak soup also uses a roux of butter and maida cooked with milk. Swasthi’s sweet corn soup uses a cornflour slurry, and so does the Jainworld tomato soup.

For a cornflour slurry, the starch maker Argo says: “Gradually stir corn starch into cold liquid until completely smooth.” It explains that corn starch “blends more easily with cold liquids than flour because it doesn’t absorb liquid until it’s cooked” (Argo). Swasthi adds that her soup “will thicken further upon cooling”, so stop a little thinner than you want.

Her page also offers a starch-free option: blend about a cup of corn with half a cup of water and stir it in. It suggests a small potato too, which a Jain household would skip.

How Do You Blend Hot Soup Safely?

Slowly, and with the jar not overfilled. Vitamix’s owner’s manual says: “When blending hot liquids or ingredients in the container, use caution; spray or escaping steam may cause burns. NEVER fill the container above the marked ‘MAXIMUM CAPACITY’ line.” It also says to “ALWAYS begin processing on the lowest speed setting” (Vitamix manual, 2024).

That manual is for one blender range, so read the manual for your own mixer. Hebbar’s tomato, palak, pumpkin and dal soups each cool the mixture, partly or fully, before blending. In our reading, that lowers the risk the manual describes.

A bunch of fresh spinach leaves on a wooden cutting board, with red tomatoes, green bell peppers and walnuts in a small pot on the table behind it

How Could You Adapt a Winter Vegetable Soup at Home?

These are our suggestions, not tested recipes.

  1. Start from the closest recipe. The Jainworld tomato soup already has no onion or garlic. The dal soup has no onion, so leaving out garlic, ginger and carrot changes it least.
  2. Remove, then taste. Leave out onion, garlic, ginger and carrot, then adjust salt, pepper and sourness at the end.
  3. Replace the body, not the flavour. If a soup loses thickness, use blending, a cornflour slurry or a little more dal.
  4. Ask about ginger, pumpkin, lauki and hing before you use them for a Jain guest.
  5. Use water or a suitable stock. Our guide to published vegetable stocks found that every recipe it read uses onion or garlic, and outlines a small test batch for households that avoid them.

For cooling, storing and reheating, the steps in that stock guide combine a University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension page on serving soup safely with NHS guidance, so they apply to soup too.

What This Guide Does Not Verify

We could not open the Jain-labelled soups on Tarla Dalal or the soups on Veg Recipes of India, so they are not included. We found no reliable source on ginger, pumpkin, lauki or hing in Jain cooking. Lauki is from a personal blog. We did not cook these soups or test our suggestions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do most soup recipes use onion and garlic?

In our sample, yes. All six published recipes we read, for tomato, palak, pumpkin, sweet corn, dal and lauki soup, use garlic. Four use onion, one uses spring onion, and only the dal soup has neither. Four of the six also use ginger, carrot or both, so check every ingredient before cooking for a Jain household.

How do you make a Jain tomato soup?

The tomato soup in Jainworld’s Jain recipe collection uses tomatoes, water, milk, a teaspoon of corn flour, butter, optional cream, pepper and salt, with no onion or garlic and no substitute. The tomatoes are pressure cooked and sieved, and the corn flour is dissolved in milk and boiled to thicken.

How do you thicken soup without potato?

The six recipes we read use four methods: blending the vegetables or dal, adding cream, cooking a butter and flour roux with milk, or stirring in a cornflour slurry. Argo, a corn starch maker, says to stir corn starch into cold liquid until smooth before adding it. Swasthi notes her sweet corn soup thickens further as it cools.

Do Jains eat pumpkin and lauki?

We found no reliable source that answers this. Jain sources we read describe root vegetables as avoided, and one lists cabbage and brinjal too, but none mentions pumpkin or bottle gourd. Practice differs between families, so ask the household you are cooking for before you include either vegetable.

Is it safe to blend hot soup in a mixer?

Take care. Vitamix’s manual warns that hot liquids can spray or release steam and cause burns, says not to fill above the maximum line, and says to start on the lowest speed. Read your own mixer’s manual. Four Hebbar’s Kitchen recipes cool the mixture before blending, which in our reading reduces the risk.

Conclusion

Most popular winter vegetable soups rely on onion and garlic, so a Jain or no-onion kitchen has to adapt them rather than follow them.

  • Read the list first: all six recipes we read use garlic, and five use onion or spring onion.
  • A Jain-listed soup leaves them out: Jainworld’s tomato soup adds no substitute.
  • Thicken another way: blending, cream, roux or a cold cornflour slurry.
  • Ask about doubtful vegetables: pumpkin, lauki, cabbage and hing all vary by household.
  • Blend with care: low speed, and never above the maximum line.

About the author: Chef Monila Surana is Managing Partner and lead culinary educator at Florence Academy of World Cuisines, Ahmedabad, with 18 years of experience in culinary education and curriculum design.

Want to cook confidently for Jain and vegetarian households? See our Culinary Foundation Program or the Nutrition and Dietetics course. Join 2,000+ students who’ve trained with expert chefs at Florence Academy, Ahmedabad.

Ready to learn from expert chefs? Explore Courses at Florence Academy →

Call us at +91 6351665305 | +91 8320715588

Have questions? Chat with us on WhatsApp — we respond fast.

Get Started

Start Your Course Today!

Illustration for the “which cooking course is right for you” quiz section on the Florence Academy homepage
Florence Academy of World Cuisines student practicing in the kitchen
Florence Academy of World Cuisines student practicing in the kitchen
Florence Academy of World Cuisines student practicing in the kitchen

Trusted by over 2K+ students

Inquire Now